ASE-certified technicians. Top-quality parts. Honest pricing. Serving Brighton and the greater Rochester area for over 90 years.
From routine maintenance to complex diagnostics — we handle it all with the same precision and care that has kept Rochester drivers coming back since 1932.
Regular, quality maintenance is the single best investment you can make in your vehicle. We use top-grade oil and filters to keep your engine clean and running strong.
Don't wait on your brakes. We inspect, service, and replace brake pads, rotors, and calipers — using quality parts built to stop you safely.
Mounting, balancing, rotation, and flat repair. We carry a wide selection of brands and sizes to fit your vehicle and your budget.
When the check engine light comes on, we get answers fast. Our diagnostic equipment pinpoints the issue so repairs are done right the first time.
Protect your tires and improve handling. We use precision equipment to ensure your vehicle tracks straight and steers true.
Fluid changes, filter replacement, and complete transmission repair. Keep your drivetrain shifting smoothly for the long haul.
Stay comfortable in every season. We diagnose and repair heater cores, AC compressors, blower motors, and handle refrigerant recharges.
Batteries, alternators, starters, and full electrical diagnostics. We trace the source of the problem and fix it correctly.
Muffler replacement, exhaust pipe and manifold repair, catalytic converter service. We keep you running quiet and passing emissions.
Safety and emissions inspections performed on-site. Fast turnaround — appointments recommended.
Elmer's Brighton Garage has been a fixture on Monroe Avenue for over 90 years. What started as a family operation is still a family operation — same commitment, same street, same standards that built this reputation one honest repair at a time.
We've never needed gimmicks. Fix it right, charge a fair price, treat every customer like a neighbor. That philosophy hasn't changed, even as the technology has. Our ASE-certified technicians use the latest diagnostic equipment and only install high-quality parts.
Whether it's your daily commuter or a vehicle you've had for decades, you can trust us to take care of it. That's a promise we've kept for more than 90 years — and one we intend to keep for 90 more.
| Monday | 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Tuesday | 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Wednesday | 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Thursday | 7:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Friday | 7:00 AM – 5:30 PM |
| Saturday | Closed |
| Sunday | Closed |
"Elmer's has been our family's go-to shop for over 15 years. They're honest, fair, and they always explain what actually needs to be done — never trying to upsell you on things you don't need."
"Brought my car in for a check engine light on a Tuesday morning. They diagnosed it same day, called me with a clear explanation, and had it fixed and ready by 4 PM. Absolutely top-notch."
"I've been coming to Elmer's for over 20 years. You will not find a more trustworthy shop in Rochester. Fair prices, quality work, and they genuinely care about their customers."